Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of clinical trials included in the meta-analysis

From: The efficacy and safety of combination of PD-1 and CTLA-4 inhibitors: a meta-analysis

Study (phase)

First author

Cancer type

Treatment arm

(No. of patients)

Control arm 1

(No. of patients)

Control arm 2

(No. of patients)

Refs.

Alliance A091401

Phase 2

D’Angelo SP

Sarcoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (42)

Nivolumab (43)

 

[29]

CheckMate 032

Phase 1/2

Janjigian YY

Esophagogastric Cancer

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (101)

Nivolumab (59)

 

[13]

CheckMate 067

Phase 3

Hodi FS

Melanoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (314)

Nivolumab (316)

Ipilimumab (315)

[30]

CheckMate 069

Phase 2

Hodi FS

Melanoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (95)

Ipilimumab (47)

 

[31]

CheckMate 214

Phase 3

Motzer RJ

Renal-Cell Carcinoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (550)

Sunitinib (546)

 

[32]

CheckMate 227a

Phase 3

Hellmann MD

NSCLC

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (583)

Nivolumab (396)

Chemotherapy (583)

[33]

NCT02374242b

Phase 2

Long GV

Melanoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (35)

Nivolumab (31)

 

[34]

Checkmate 143c

Phase 1

Omuro A

Glioblastoma

Nivolumab plus

Ipilimumab (10)

Nivolumab (10)

 

[35]

  1. NSCLC non-small-cell lung cancer
  2. a583, 396, and 583 patients were assigned to Nivolumab plus Ipilimumab group, Nivolumab group, and Chemotherapy group in CheckMate 227 totally. However, the difference comparison among three groups was just conducted in patients harboring at least 10 mutations per megabase
  3. bNCT02374242 contained three cohorts: Cohort A (Nivolumab plus Ipilimumab, n = 35), B (Nivolumab, n = 25), and C (Nivolumab, n = 6). Among three cohorts, Cohort A and B consisted of patients with the same diagnosis and treatment. 60 patients were randomly assigned to Cohort A and B while 6 patients were selected to Cohort C. Therefore, the following analysis was based on Cohort A and B
  4. cCheckmate 143 consisted of three cohorts: Cohort A (Nivolumab, n = 10), Cohort B (Nivolumab plus Ipilimumab, n = 10), and Cohort C (Nivolumab plus Ipilimumab, n = 20). 20 glioblastoma patients were 1:1 randomly assigned to Cohort A and B while 20 patients were allocated to Cohort C. Thus, the following analysis was based on Cohort A and B